So, this is our first post. I wrote this right after I got back from the midnight screening (Three in the morning), so it is a mite rambley, but no matter. Enjoy
There are spoilers afoot, obviously, so proceed with caution. It is three in the morning. Why am I up until three in the morning? I’d really like to know myself . . . I went to the HP 5 midnight screening. Thought it was pretty cool, kids dressed up, fun waiting in line with the friends. .. then I watched the movie, and wondered who would want to stay up until 3am to watch this terrible thing. And why did I?
Now, first of all, I’m generally not a movie person. I just don’t like ‘em and I had already watched 3 movies in the previous 24 hours (Breakfast Club, Rent, Legally Blonde). So that might have something to do with it.
My problem with the last two HP movies is they have been basically a hodgepodge of the book. Order’s all messed up, characters do things other characters were supposed to do . . .and that just annoys me so much. Because it’s all hodgepodgy and they cut out conversations between characters that explain things (i.e. Harry’s and Dumbledore’s chat in his office at the very end has been cut to within an inch of its life) no one who hasn’t read the book has a prayer of following anyway, and anyone who has read the book is going to notice these discrepancies. So what exactly is the point of having them? It may be more confusing, but I would much prefer it if they kept things as close to the story as possible, plot twists and all. Simply isn’t as fun without ‘em.
Now, the 5th book is my favorite of all the Harry Potters (more on this below). So I know the dialogue very, very well. So I’d hear some lines that I know they said in the book and then I knew there would be a funny line in the book afterwards. . but it wasn’t in the movie.
i.e.:
Luna: We’ll fly, of course!
Ron: Now, maybe you can sprout wings whenever you want to, but the rest of us …
They only had the first line, how long would it have taken Ron to say that? 10 seconds? How funny would it have been? Very.
The 5th book is my favorite because Tonks is my favorite character of the series and Bellatrix is my second character (inching up to first now that Tonks and Lupin have gotten cuddly in book 6, which I don’t like/get. . . I think JKR did this just to dispel the Lupin/Sirius rumors). They had 4 lines. Total. 2 each. I counted.
I basically saw the movie because I saw pictures of Tonks and Bellatrix in advance. Wasn’t too fond of Bella’s hair, but the actresses look exactly like I pictured the characters, especially Tonks. I loved her clothes; I’m seriously considering writing to the costuming department asking where they bought them. Cute, funky, so Tonksy. (Yes, that is a word, least it is now) An issue I had was they never even explained her metamorphmagus (not quite sure if that’s spelled right, obviously spell check doesn’t know the word . . . and could it be metamorphmagusing? I think metamormagus is only the noun… ah well, you get the point). So she’s sitting at the table, transforming her nose, and her hair changes in an early scene (when she gets angry, not because she wants it to, which is wrong) and people who’ve never read the book are going to be like, WTF? Also, I don’t think they ever introduced her as Tonks, the name Tonks is mentioned, however, never in the context of the character. Moody refers to her directly as Nymphadora at one point . .. so those who haven’t read the book are going to think she’s Nymphadora and another character named Tonks is floating about. Hah.
Bellatrix was perfect. She looked the role, she acted the role . . . it was absolutely amazing. At least, her two lines were. My main complaint was the hair (in some behind-the-scenes pictures she looked like she had never met a hairbrush), but that couldn’t really be seen in the dark, so I have no complaints. Or I would have not had any if she had had more of a role . . . *rolls eyes at movie people*
Aside from their minimal roles (after the first scene I was like, okay, Christmas, then we’ll see more Tonks . . .okay, end? Dammit.) Both of them were really good and I might just get the DVD and watch the first and last scenes. Not worth it staying up until 3am though . . .
Moving on to the other characters and my other complaints:
Why must they make Neville so weak and vulnerable? In the book he really improves once Bella (I call Bellatrix Bella, I’m not quite sure why . . . shorter to type maybe) breaks out and here in the movie he was still weak and that just annoyed me. Neville might have memory issues, but in the book he’s a strong character. .. not a weak not-quite-sidekick
I also disliked the Harry/Ginny hints as they were totally slipping 6th book stuff in the there. See, normally, I wouldn’t mind (I’m not the biggest Harry/Ginny shipper, but I can deal with them getting cuddly. Not Lupin and Tonks though…), but they could slip that stuff in and not the funny lines? Why? It would take the same amount of time for Ron to say the flying line as it would for Ginny to hang back and look at Harry as he tries to talk to Cho.
Sirius dying was the lamest HP screen death (if not the lamest movie death) I have ever seen. AND they had Bella jump out of no where and do the avada-kedavra thing. Wrong. In the book, they duel for a while, and she casts a spell that gives off an unknown color of light and pushes him into the archway. That’s why Harry’s not sure if he’s dead or not… seriously movie people, would it have been so hard? They also cut out Bella explaining to Harry why his cruciatus cruse (are spelled supposed to be capitalized? One of these days, I’m going to write a Harry Potter Grammar/Spelling Guide) worked, which I loved. And it would have meant more Bella screen time if they had kept that in there…
One more last complaint: They said Lestange Le-STRANGE. As in, “That’s a mighty strange hat you’re wearing”. It’s Le-sta-on-ge. I think it’s French, not quite sure, but on the audiotapes (where the pronounce it le-stra-on-ge), Jim Dale gives her (Bella) a French accent) I really prefer that pronunciation, so every time they said le-STRAGE, I was wincing… luckily they only said it three times, so I supposed underwriting Bella was good for something.
Oh, and there were good bits. Luna Lovegood was absolutely amazing, exactly the way I pictured the character and she had a decent amount of screen time, so that was cool. Snape as always kicked ass, so excited for the 6th movie just to I can see him kill Dumbledore (I dislike the way the actor who plays Dumbledore portrays him, but I’m sure you’re getting tired of reading my complaints).
So, why you ask, did you waste a good . . . thirty-seven minutes writing this when you could be sleeping (it is now almost four am, oh boy). Well, after I watch a movie, I’m always like, “Okay . . . did I like that or not?” It’s really nice to finally have a firm opinion of a movie, because god knows I have them about everything else. Also, if any of you work for the Harry Potter movie people, considering this a list of grievances. Please fix them. I’ll send cookies
By all means, go and see it if you wish. A. . . . I really can’t stop you, and B. the Potter-Purest and movie-hater in me is writing this…
And a note to all commenters: I am aware how hard it must be to write a movie of the Harry Potter books. I know why they do it (some people like it and it’s a pretty good moneymaker). I am also aware the solution to my problem is to just not watch the movies…
-ponine